While it’s somewhat obvious which American Horror Story: Cult characters are evil (*cough, Kai, cough*), this one theory connects all the potentially evil cult members, and it makes too much sense to ignore. During this week’s episode, “Don’t Be Afraid of the Dark,” we were introduced to Ally and Ivy’s new neighbor, Meadow Wilton (Leslie Grossman), who we flagged as suspicious the second she compared Beyoncé’s “Lemonade” to her powder Crystal Light. But what’s even more sketchy is that her name perfectly aligns with the other nature-inspired character names in the series thus far.
We get it, it’s 2017 and people have some crazy names, but Reddit user thismaybemean brings up the idea that all the characters with nature-inspired names are cult members, and we’re convinced. Read on to see the proof that all cult members have similar names.